What are the common
four phenotypes of PCOS? This is important at least for treatment purpose because
till date the treatment of PCOS is mostly empirical and symptom-based As such
scientist and reproductive biologists have classified PCOS into four broad
phenotypes, though there are many other phenotypes of PCOS. Total 43 phenotypes
have been classified by some International Organizations and also by “Androgen
Excess and PCO society”. However for day to day clinical practice the following
classification seems to be more meaningful.
a) Type-I PCOS ->
Characteristic will be i) Oligomenorrhea/sometimes Secondary Amenorrhea, ii)
USG will show evidence of PCOS or PCOM, iii) evidence of hyperandrogenism, iv)
Hyperinsulinaemia woman / Normo-insulinmic woman. In 37.5% of such type-I cases
there will be clinical and laboratory metabolic syndrome. In fact this is the
commonest phenotypes of PCOS as high as 65.6% of PCOS women. If there is
documented hyperinsulinaemia then the doctor should seriously consider the
Insulin sensitizer has the first or initial drug of choice like i) Metformin,
ii) Myoinositol & other isomers, iii) Chr. Piconate, iv) NAC) Vit-D à preferred initial agent will be drugs to combat IR not the
Ovulogens).
b) hyperandrogenaemia /Normo-androgenic women –If
hyperandrogenaemic: -- TR by OCP / Pre Tr. With Inj Agonist in mid luteal
phase/ Progesterone
c) Eumneorrhoic or oligomenorrhoea woman –If history is oligomenorrheicà Primary agent of Ry will
be CC/Anastrazole/ Gonadotrophins in cases who are oligomenorrheic.
d) Fertility restoration seeking women --who demonstrate unusual raise
value of DHEASO4/ T4:- to find out source of Testosterone by special tests-ACTH
stimulation tests, Serum cortisol etc, 17-OH P etc.
To note that most Obese
PCOS, even average weight PCOS women will mandate Lifestyle modification, Exercise,
Dietary Modification, Vit-D supplementation if serum level is low, Anti-oxidant
to prevent onward vascular damage and only on few occasion some PCOS women will
have to take Orlistat (if obesity but overweight women) and lipid lowering
agents particularly if triglyceride levels are high. Etc.
Therefore my
proposition to Forum members is to diagnose or pinpoint the exact pathology the
candidate is suffering from instead of putting her in a broad category of PCOS
which encompasses any many many metabolic/ hormonal abnormalities, for example
a woman may be designated as a) normo insulinaemic, b) hyperandrogenic, c)
oligomenorrheic d) normal weight e) anovulatory woman instead if labeling her
PCOS. What is the view f Forum members about such stratifying in initial diag
work up? The limitations are initial high cost of Lab tests and difficult to
interpret the Lab values of insulin / Testosterone. Unfortunately the Lb methodology
of these two hormonal parameters (Insulin/ T4) has not been standardized.
This reminds me our
ward Round in Medicine indoor –where one our Visiting was always unhappy to
hear the term Mitral stenosis. Instated he insisted that we should write the
diagnosis in the following format e.g. 1) Rheumatic 2) mitral stenosis with
3) normal heart rate( means no
fibrillation) with 4) no failure and 5) no clinical evidence of
Pulm oedema who had no previous surgery for stenosis. He insisted that will
help the clinician to formulate TR Plan. I, follow his path of thinking. I hope
we can apply his philosophy in posed PCOS cases more appropriately.
`Etc d) ovulatory /anovulatory. Admittedly ,
Lab diagnosis of hyperinsulimeania and or hyperandrogenaemias difficult but
honestly speaking have a feeling that all women seeking fertility Tr who are
primarily labeled as PCOS/ PCOM should have identification of the type and
degree of metabolic milieu or hormonal milieu so as to maximize the choice of
or selection of initial protocol.
For instance if LH is
high and Ovarian Volume is > 12 CC3à then LOD may be given priority to maximize the efficacy of Tr.
By contras if there is predominate hyperinsuineamia in a clinically suspected PCOS we can allow fair
trial of in, sensitizers for couple of months without resorting
to CC/Anastrozole or gonadotrophin inj-not to speck of ART.
No comments:
Post a Comment