Let us discuss on role of progesterone in postmenopausal
women A) To control hot flush B) Night sweat C) To prevent osteoporosis D) Progesterone
in Alzheimer ’s disease,
Auto immune diseases, Multiple sclerosis? What is the action of Progesterone in
human brain??? ??
Actions of each progesterone are not alike!!! Therefore a judicious selection of use
of synthetic progestogens which are in clinical use during the menopause and
post menopause, are warranted. Newer
evidence from molecular and genomic studies suggests that not all progestins
have the same effect.
Each progestin
has its own biocharcteristics regarding breast cancer as in other clinical
conditions.
.
Progesterone has been shown to have neuroprotective effects and is used in various
brain injuries .Progesterone has both genomic and non-genomic actions. A) What about genomic action of progesterones??? Ans: The genomic action is the classical reaction whereby the
hormone progesterone, acting as a ligand, connects to its receptor in the
nucleus and initiates new mRNA protein synthesis. This is a relatively slow
process.
B) What about nongenomic action of progesterones?? The rapid action
of progestogens is due to non-genomic actions in which intracellular signaling
pathways are activated resulting in alteration of ions fluxes and intracellular
calcium concentration within seconds . The non genomic actions also induce
second messengers, such as cyclic nucleotides and extracellular regulated
kinases .These actions are specific to each individual progestogen.
Which progesterone –When? How best to select
type of progesterone in menopausal years?? As synthetic progestogens differ in
actions, proper selection is necessary for successful therapy in treating 1) menopausal
symptoms or 2) reducing the risk of diseases associated with the menopause.
Use of
synthetic progestogens is in clinical use during the menopause and post
menopause, most notably are as follows A)
Hot flush adjunct to estrogen replacement therapy but no increased
prevalence of Breast cancer .
Progestogens
are necessary in order to prevent endometrial hyperplasia caused by unopposed
estrogen and in recent years, large clinical trials have shown that the
association of progestins with estrogen in HRT might raise the risk of breast
cancer, but this risk was not confirmed in ongoing clinical studies which have
not shown that trend .
B) Postmenopausal
use of Progestogens to prevent Osteoporosis!!
Progestogens
alone have a very limited effect on bone mineral density (BMD). But,
pretreatment with estrogen for 4-7 days has been shown to induce progesterone
receptors in osteoblasts .
This
explains the beneficial effect on BMD, in all clinical trials in which
progestogens were added to estrogen.
What about MPA?? Ans: Medroxyprogesterone
acetate (MPA) decreases BMD, both in the hips and spine, in the first 2 years
of use, followed by a slight increase.
What about Primolut N/ Crina CR with
low dose of natural orstrogens ?? Ans :- Norethisterone
is a synthetic progestin derived from 19-nortestosterone. It binds and
activates the progesterone receptor twice as much as progesterone itself, with
low androgenic and estrogenic activities attributed to its metabolites The
effect of norethisterone acetate (NETA) with a low dose of 17(3-estardiol) on BMD has been investigated in a randomized
placebo control study .There was a significant increase in BMD both in the
lumbar spine (5.2 %) and the hip (3.1 %) compared to the placebo group (-0.9%).
Serum
concentration of osteocalcin decreased by approximately 34 %, bone-specific
alkaline phosphatase decreased by about 30 %, and C-terminal propepetide of
type I collagen decreased by 20 %. Controversially, inhibition of the nuclear
progesterone receptor has been found to augment bone mass, resulting in higher
BMD .
C) Use of progesterone in ht flush alone??Role of synthetic
progesterone in control of Hot Flush and
Night Sweats?? Ans:
In this settings best progesterone will be nightly micronized progesterone (300
mg) or medroxyprogesterone acetate (MPA) 10 mg/day. that micronized progesterone and pregnane derivates are safer with
regard to VTE risk.
These have
been shown to cause an overall decrease in the number of daily hot flushes and
night sweats by 59 %. Extension of this study has shown that micronized
progesterone is also effective for severe vasomotor symptoms and that
progesterone withdrawal is not followed by a rebound increase in vasomotor
symptoms .A similar effect has been shown for medroxyprogesterone acetate
(MPA) 10 mg/day. But MPA, by activating
glucocorticoid receptors, potentiate the vascular effects of thrombin
A study
in which patients received either conjugated equine estrogen (CEE), (0.6
mg/day) or MPA for 1 year. MPA was found to be equivalent to CEE in the control
of vasomotor symptoms in women. Therefore progestogens(MPA) can be initiated soon after the surgery of TAH & BSO with
identical efficacy like combined HRT.
D)
Vasomotor symptoms: Drug selection of steroid group!!!! A great dilemma –Only Oestrogens,
only Progesterone or combined Oetsrogen & progesterone ?? Ans & Logic:-
Oral progestins have been shown to be effective for vasomotor symptoms in
several randomized placebo controlled trial .Mode of action of HRT to control hot flush which is fortunately
less common in our country? Mode of action of each hormone?? Estrogen alleviates hot flushes
by lowering levels of serotonin and noradrenaline in the brain .Progestogens may act in a
different manner. Progesterone acts on the hypothalamus changing the frequency
of LH pulses, increasing basal temperature and stimulating respiration.
Therefore progesterone and progestins have various effects on the hypothalamus,
from which hot flushes are thought to generate
Risk of combined HRT
??? Does Progesterone promotes Venous Thromboembolism?? Micronized
progesterone and pregnane derivates are safer with regard to VTE risk.
Progestins,
when given alone (e.g. progestin only contraceptive pills), carry little, if
any, risk of VTE. Randomized controlled studies and meta-analyses of
observational studies suggest that the risk of venous thrombo-embolism (VTE) is
higher among users of combined estrogen and progestogen than among users of
estrogen alone. Oral estrogens increase the VTE risk while transdermal
estrogens appear to be safe with respect to thrombotic risk .However, MPA, by
activating glucocorticoid receptors, potentiate the vascular effects of
thrombin .The ESTHER study (Estrogen and Thromboembolism Risk) looked into the
risk of VTE in French postmenopausal women treated with HRT. This study was
the first to establish a differential association of VTE risk related to the
progestogen used. The results were irrespective of the route of estrogen
administration. The results showed that
micronized progesterone and pregnane derivates are safer with regard to VTE risk.
The norpregnane derivatives were associated with a significant increase in VTE
risk
The
norpregnanes are potent progestogens with antiestrogenic activity. Women
suffering from hyperestrogenic effects, such as breast tenderness or
endometrial hyperplasia are more likely to benefit from this type of
progestogens.
F)
What are the actions of Progesterone on the Brain??
Progesterone
is metabolized in the brain by 5a-reductase to 5a-dihydroprogesterone. This in
turn is further metabolized by 3a-hydroxysteroid dehydrogenase to the
neurosteroid allopregnanolone.
The
neurosteroids are modulatory ligands for a variety of neurotransmitters and
nuclear steroid hormone receptors. Allopregnanolone crosses the blood-brain barrier.
It has been shown in rodents, that allopregnanolone is an efficacious proliferative
agent (both in vitro and in-vivo studies) It also decreases amyloid protein in human
neural stem cells .Progesterone metabolites exert considerable sedative
effects after binding to the GABAA receptor . Neurosteroids such as preg-
nanolone affect synaptic functions and myelinization. Their action is mediated
through inhibition of the glycogen synthase kinase (GSK-3[5) pathway (much like
most
bipolar mood stabilizers such as lithium) .Neurosteroids are modulatory ligands
for a variety of neurotransmitters and nuclear steroid hormone receptors. Progesterone
has been shown to reduce inflammatory reactions commonly seen in MS, by the
direct effect of progesterone on astrocytes and microglia
H) How
efcetive is Progesterone in
Alzheimer’s Disease??
Estradiol
increases the expression of the progesterone-synthesizing enzymes. Estradiol
increases the expression in the hypothalamus, and especially in the astrocytes.
Astrocytes are the most active steroidogenic cells in CNS and contribute to
neuro-protection Treatment with different types of progestogens found that
these compounds may promote neurogenesis, neural survival, myelinization and
increases memory .There is some data that suggests that allopregnanolone may maintain
the regenerative ability of the brain and also can modify the progression of
Alzheimer’s disease .Progesterone has been shown to improve impaired axonal
transport, a key event of the aging brain. Reduced axonal transport has been
proposed to play an early and causative role in the development of Alzheimer’s
disease. In mouse models, reduced axonal transport may lead to aberrant
amyloid-p peptide formation and subsequently to neurodegeneration .
Traumatic
Brain Injury (TBI)
In TBI,
whether post menopausal or not, the use of progesterone was found to be
effective in reducing brain damage.. In brief, data is available showing that
progesterone reduces edema, restores the blood-brain barrier, protects against
secondary neuronal death and promotes behavioral recovery after TBI A phase II clinical trial, the ProTECT study,
has shown more than 50 %
reduction in mortality in mortality in severe TBI and a statistically
significant improvement in functional outcome in patients with moderate BTI,
when treatment was administered no later than 2 h after sustaining BTI
Take
home message about Combined HRT or progesterone alone in hot flush & osteoporosis
Progesterone
and progestogens have a significant role in various clinical situations
throughout life. As the novel actions of progestogens are elucidated it is
clear that these hormones have influence on the outcome of many clinical
conditions.
It is
important to bear in mind that there is no class effect of all these compounds.
Each has its own clinical, biochemical and molecular specific effects. In depth
knowledge of the physio-pathological effects of each progestogen will enable
their better use in many clinical conditions such as hot flushes, brain trauma,
sleep disorder and more. The most serious clinical side effects are the raised
risk of breast cancer associated with some progestogens (e.g. MPA) but not with
others such as micronized progesterone. MPA has also been shown to inhibit some
of the beneficial effects of estradiol on the CNS. The fact that numerous
coregulators affect the end result of ligand-progesterone receptors (both
nuclear and membrane) indicates to the complexities of
progesterone/progestogens actions. Receptor affinity alone does not determine
potency. Our present understanding is that the affinity, potency and efficacy
of progestogens are substantially different between the different types of
progestogens and are tissue specific.
.
No comments:
Post a Comment